#TKLucky7 2 Doors Down 5D Mark II abandoned Able Sense agave AGNS al fresco Alderney Market almonds Annapolis Valley anniversary aperitif Aperol appetizers apple butter apples aqua arancini Arborio architecture argus 75 Argyle Street Ashwood Ridge Asian-inspired dishes auction avocado award baby backyard bacon baconandbaileys Baileys baked apples baking banana banana bread bars basil Baskin Robbins BBQ beach beef Benjamin Bridge best carrot cake ever best carrot cake recipe ever bird's nest birthday biscotti biscuits Bish Bishop's Cellar black plums blood orange blood orange marmalade blue blue cheese blueberries book review Boston Bourbon brandy bread breakfast Brewery Market bride brie brioche brisket Brooklyn Brooklyn Warehouse brown butter brown sugar bud buds Bulk Barn bunny buns butcher butter buttercream Cabot Links cake cakes Campari candied bacon Canon Canon 5D Mark 2 Cape Breton Carbonara card cardamom carrot cake carrots cats chai chalkboard charcuterie cheesecake cherries chicken chicken salad chili paste Chinese New Year Chinese wedding chocolate Chocolate Lake Christmas christmas photo cards cilantro cinnamon citrus recipe Clafoutis Clam Harbour Classic Cocktails Clementine cobalt blue cocktail cocktail photography Cocktails coconut coconut macaroon pie crust coconut milk coffee Colosseum colour comfort food condensed milk contest cookbook cookies cooking cooks corn corn field Cornwall cracker crust crafting Cranberry Madeira Crawfish cream cheese cream cheese frosting cream sauce crockpot croquettes crostata CTV culinary guide cupcakes Curry custard da Maurizio dahlia dates David Lebovitz DesBarres Manor Inn dessert Diana Domaine de Grand Pre Donna Hay dried dulce de leche Earl Grey early morning east coast living magazine easter Easy Easy Asian Easy Italian-Asian Easy To Make EatInEatOut editorial eggs elderflower engagement Europe extra toes fall family fans farm farmer's market feathers february Feel Good Food Feisty Chef Festive feta Fine Cooking Magazine Fine Lifestyles Magazine Halifax firefighter fish in parchment Fish Sauce fish taco flax flea market Florence flourless flowers fog food Food and Wine food bloggers Food Bloggers of Canada food film food photographer food photography food photography tips food styling food stylist food video food vignette forest Forum fountain france French French wine fresh fresh herbs Friends friendship frozen fruit fruit butter fudge fundraiser garden garlic garlic scapes Getaway Giada de Laurentiis Gin ginger girl glamour Glen Arbor gluten free GMCR gnocchi golden hour golden spiral gorgonzola granola green Grilling groom guacamole guanciale Hali Deli Halifax Halifax fashion photography Halifax Food Bloggers Halifax food photographer Halifax food photography Halifax food styling halifax food stylist Halifax newborn photography Halifax photographer Halifax photography Halifax restaurant Halifax restaurant photography Halifax restaurants Halifax wedding photographer haskap hazelnut heart Heart and Stroke hfxfb HHalifax photographer holiday home homemade homemade liqueur homemade tacos honey house Hurricanes hydrangea ice cream ice cream sandwiches icing sugar Idiot Cake il Mercato il Mercato Spring Garden Indian ingredients iPhone Italian Italy ivory jam jane's next door jane's on the common January Jeffrey Van Horne Jennie Dobbs JIVE Photographic Joy The Baker Julia Child juniper berries JVH K-Cups Keurig kids Kingsburg kitchen vignette kitchenaid lace Lamborghini Larry Uteck lavender Le Caveau Le French Fix leftovers lemon lemon bars lemon curd lemon curdsicles light lighting lime linguine Live at 5 lobster Local Lord Nelson love Lulu and Po Lunenburg mac and cheese macarons macaroons Made With Local magnolia tree Makin' Bacon Manitoba many feet maple maple rosemary almonds marble Maritime Museum of the Atlantic Marsala marshmallow Martha Stewart Martha Stewart CAKES Martinis mason jar meatballs meatloaf medjool dates menu meringue Merry Christmas Mexican Michelangelo Milan mini eggs MINI Plus mint mint green Minted.com models monthly miettes morning Morris East MRB muffins mushrooms My Paris Kitchen Nanny Burke Nanny Neil nautical 'Nduja Negroni New Orleans New Year's Eve Nova Scotia NSLC Nutella oak island inn oats Occasions olive olive oil Orange oranges orchid Out Of Old Nova Scotia Kitchens overnight oats Oxford Pad Thai Noodle Pie painting with light pancetta Pantheon paper paperie parents Paris park Parrsboro party decor party food pasta pastry pasty Pavlova peach peaches peacock peanut butter pear Pearl pecans pepper Pete's phlox photographer picnic pie pink pink grapefruit pink peppercorns Pinterest pistachio pizza pizza Halifax Playbook plums Point Pleasant Park polenta polydactal pom pom pom poms porcini pork belly potatoes pp Neil preserves pretty product shots prosciutto Prosecco published pudding pudding pops pulled pork Purcell's Cove purple quail Quick Meals Quinoa rain Raincoast Crisps rainy day Random House of Canada RANS raspberries raspberry Ratinaud recipe red red currants restaurant Restaurant Association rhubarb Rice Krispies rice noodles rice pudding risotto Ritz roasted almonds roasted garlic roasted red chiili paste rolls Rolls Royce Rome romesco rose rosemary rum rustik magazine Sackville sage salsa salsa doña San Fiorano sand santa Saskatoon berries sausage Savour scones Scotch Scott Jones sculptures sea salt Seahorse Sweets Seaport Market seeds shortbread shortcrust shrimp simply balance sister skillet Skor Bits smoked salmon snack snickerdoodles soup Spanish spice spicy Thai mango spring Spring Garden Road sprinkles squares St. Famille St. Margaret's Bay St. Mary's Basilica stamp stars steak Stephanie Bertossi still life storyteller strawberry strobes studio Stuffed Pork Chops summer Summer Fresh sun Sunday sunrise sunset supper sweet potato syrup tarts Taste of Nova Scotia tea teabiscuits Texas Thai Thai Cooking Thai food Thai Kitchen Thai Kitchen Canada thank you The Bicycle Thief The Bitter End The Coast The Hugo The Vatican thyme Tidal Bay Tiramisu tissue tissue paper toast toasted tomato Toronto tracks Trajan's Forum travel Trevi Fountain TTV twinkle lights Untitled Eats Valentine's Day Van Houtte vanilla vegetables Venice Vermouth versailles video vin d'orange vintage vintage bakeware Vittorio VW wallpaper washi tape waterfront wax paper wedding Westin whipped cream white white wine wild strawberries Willy Krauch window Windsor wine wine jelly winery Winners Wolfville wood wreath writer Wuthering Heights yellow Zabaglione
« Florence ~ Part 1 | Main | Sweet Potato Soup with Acadian Maple Syrup »

Vanilla Bean Buttercream Dream {aka Nanny Burke's Buttercream}

I finally did it.

After four failed attempts, I finally made the buttercream I've been dreaming of. And it's all thanks to Nanny Burke.

You may remember my first attempt. Sure they looked good (and the cupcake itself was pretty good) but the frosting had as much flavour as a of a jar of Vaseline and the texture to match.

Then last week, I made Bacon and Baileys cupcakes. I used what I thought was a decent buttercream recipe but really, all you could taste was icing sugar. In an attempt to rescue it, I glugged in a bunch of Baileys. As you can see in the photos, it was somewhat of a droopy, oozy mess. 

On Thursday, a really cute girl I know, A, said 'Oh - you need Nanny Burke's recipe!!' She e-mailed Nanny Burke in Cape Breton and asked for the recipe on my behalf. Nanny told A that over the last 50 years, she's tried a TON of buttercream recipes and this one was by far the best (and the easiest). On Friday I got a text from A with the recipe and a few notes from Nanny Burke.

So why, oh why didn't I follow my gut and trust the wisdom and experience of Nanny Burke? {sigh}

You see, I woke up Saturday morning, inspired by a recipe I had seen online for Swiss Buttercream. Ooooooh - a beautiful meringue-based buttercream that even a beginner could make without screwing up? Or so the recipe implies. Well guess what? I wasted 8 eggs and 4 sticks of butter on a nasty curdled bowl of grossness that I hurled into my green bin in a fit of frustration. 

And then I turned to Nanny Burke.

Oh Nanny Burke, I know we've never met, but after making your buttercream, I consider us kin.

Nanny Burke's Buttercream is the stuff dreams are made of. As I was piping this perfect marriage of buttery sweetness atop my vanilla cupcakes, I constantly stopped to pipe some onto my fingertip. Some for the cupcakes, some for me, some for the cupcakes, some for me...

Ok, so are you ready for the recipe? It's ridiculously easy and by far the BEST frosting I have EVER had!!

Nanny Burke's Buttercream

2 Cups Unsalted Butter, room-temp/soft (I used 1.5 Cups Salted Butter and 1/2 Cup Crisco for firmness)

1 lb icing sugar, sifted (I used 4 Cups, unsifted - I'm lazy sometimes)

1 tsp Vanilla (I used Vanilla Bean Paste)

1/8 tsp salt (I omitted the Salt because I used Salted Butter)

Notes from Nanny Burke

~ Don't mix for more than 2-3 minutes

~ Sub in shortening for butter if you want to decorate with flowers or want a firmer texture

~ Make it once and then play with it

On a side note, here's something interesting that happened when I was baking these cupcakes. I used Ina Garten's recipe for Coconut Cupcakes without the coconut. I baked the first dozen at 350 degrees until golden on top, about 22 minutes. Then I had another look at the recipe and realized that I was supposed to bake them at 325. So I reduced the temperature on the oven for the second batch. Here's what happened:

I've discovered that it is MUCH easier to decorate a cupcake when the top of the cupcake is puffed up into a little dome. Anyway, it doesn't really matter because both batches were absolutely delicious (next time though, I think I'll omit the almond extract in the cupcakes and double up on the vanilla). Today is Tuesday, I baked these on Sunday and they are still tender and moist. I'd recommend making them for sure.

Whew - I did it!! I finally did it!!

Reader Comments (38)

I can't wait to try this buttercream recipe....They look amazing Kelly!

April 5, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterAngela

two cups of butter :) that's how you make great frosting!

May 18, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterDina

Oh, I'm so sorry to hear my Swiss meringue buttercream didn't work for you! If you're inclined, shoot me an email; I'd love to troubleshoot it and get to the bottom of what went wrong for you. Cheers!

May 18, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterStella

Just a note about Swiss Buttercream... when it gets curdled like that, it usually means your meringue wasn't cool enough or your butter was too warm. But have no fear! Just pop the curdled mess in the fridge for about 15 minutes and then whip, whip, whip it! I PROMISE that it will come together.

May 19, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterJ

good it be so simple. I've tried to make a good buttercream many times...maybe I'll give this one a try soon.

May 20, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterLian

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>